St Catherine's College Oxford

Search

Making Madness Visible. Ethics of the Gaze and Mental Disorders

When the American psychologist David Rosenhan asked the rhetorical question, ‘If sanity and insanity exist, how shall we know them?’, he was questioning the diagnostic criteria of 1970s psychiatry. In my book, I answer neither the question of whether sanity and insanity exist, nor that of whether we can reliably tell them apart. Instead, I trace, across history and cultures, one of the answers humans have repeatedly given to this centuries-old question: we know sanity from insanity by making madness visible. This process of visualisation is, at the same time, a process of othering: the insane are marked as different and thereby identified as outsiders. Drawing on examples from my monograph, this paper traces the history of some of the main tropes through which madness has been visualised and othered, paying particular attention to the reciprocal relationship between visual representation and the practices—of treatment, identification, confinement and marginalisation, among others—that have historically surrounded madness.

Co-creation and the quest for agency in behavioural public policy

Interest in behavioural public policy has grown rapidly, but some have raised concerns that behavioural interventions may undermine human agency. Many of these interventions rely on top-down processes in which policymakers and experts define both policy goals and the shape of the interventions themselves. This top-down stance raises concerns about paternalism, limited stakeholder buy-in, and reduced effectiveness in complex, large-scale societal challenges. This is despite that behavioural policy, such as nudges and boosts, specifically purports to safeguard individual agency and autonomy.
This talk proceeds in two moves. First, it articulates the conception of agency underlying mainstream behavioural public policy. Drawing on a range of approaches in philosophy of action, it shows that there are many aspects of agency that mainstream behavioural policy ignores. Second, it explores whether co-creation as a methodology could help behavioural policy address agency as a subjective experience and a social phenomenon. This talk is based on joint work with Jarno Tuominen.

Minoritised Scholars in Academic Research: A Proposal for Inclusive Practice

One of the key roles of academics who research phenomena which are related to their own minoritisation (“minoritised scholars”) is to bring innovation to research by having been sensitised to problematic aspects of the existing scholarship through their own lived experience. Yet, they face a number of well-documented difficulties, including epistemic oppression, epistemic injustice, epistemic exploitation, excess epistemic deference and microaggression. While these problems are clearly documented, few solutions are currently offered. In this paper I suggest that some aspects of democratic deliberation could be usefully applied here. I discuss three of these aspects: boundary-setting, agenda-setting and countertalk.

Search the VBP Website