St Catherine's College Oxford

Search

Calculating Experience? A New Role for Phenomenology in the Development and Application of Artificial Intelligence for Mental Health 

Home >> VBP Meetings Webinars ASS >> Calculating Experience? A New Role for Phenomenology in the Development and Application of Artificial Intelligence for Mental Health 

Calculating Experience? A New Role for Phenomenology in the Development and Application of Artificial Intelligence for Mental Health

12 February 2025 9.30-16.30
St Catherine’s College Oxford and Online

Meeting Details


This seminar will reflect on the possibilities of integrating phenomenology (with its focus on lived experience, embodiment, intersubjectivity, and empathy) with “conscious-less” artificial intelligence technologies. It will explore the potential of the phenomenological approach to contribute to computational approaches to psychopathology and vice versa to advance synthetic phenomenology for mental health care.

 

approach to contribute to computational approaches to psychopathology and vice versa to advance synthetic phenomenology for mental health care.

 

Time Topics Speakers
09:30 Coffee + Registration
10:00 Introduction Bill Fulford & Marcin Moskalewicz
10:15 Session 1
  LLMs and the Patterns of Human Language Use

 

Christoph Durt (Munich)
  LLMs, Cognitive Biases, and the Path to Cognitive Humility Marcin Rządeczka & Maciej Wodziński (Lublin)
11:15 Discussion  Discussant: TBA
11.30 Q&A
11:45 Break
12.00 Session 2
  Psychopathology and AI: How Analytic German Idealism May Bridge the Gap Peter Schönknecht (Leipzig)
  Quantifying Borderline Experience

 

Marcin Moskalewicz, Marta Sokół, Anastazja Szuła, Anna Sterna (Poznan/Warsaw/Lublin)
13:00 Discussion Discussant: Anastasios Dimopoulous (London)
13.15 Q&A
13:30 Lunch
14:30 Session 3
  Limits of Formalization. Which Aspects of the Human Experience Can Enter Algorithmic Models? Marianne Broeker (Oxford)
  Computational Phenomenology and Deep Learning Pierre Beckmann (Lausanne)
  Computational (Neuro) Phenomenology Maxwell Ramstead (London/Montreal)
16:00 Discussion Discussant: Philipp Schmidt-Boddy (Heidelberg)
16:15 Q&A
16.30 Closing Remarks

The standard phenomenological approach toward the developments in AI-assisted healthcare underscores its drawbacks. It is argued that large language models behind virtual therapeutic agents lack embodied know-how and authentic engagement, that simulated subjectivity has no intentionality and style, and that mimicking empathy is not care. At the same time, a phenomenological interpretation of artificial neural networks as representing the dynamic nature of consciousness is conceivable, and it allows us to imagine the possibilities of computational phenomenology in silico. This seminar shall explore the possibilities for critically integrating phenomenology with artificial intelligence, and in particular, issues related to:

  • Implementation of AI systems for qualitative phenomenological research, quantitative analysis of lived experience, and specification of phenomenal states
  • Enhancing affect recognition and minimizing bias reinforcement in chatbot design for vulnerable groups; conceptual/linguistic vs embodied/enacted resonance and understanding
  • The role of simulated care and meaning-making, digital empathy, and semblance of agency for the safe and effective use of AI in mental health care
  • Integration of AI tools with values-based practice; alignment with human values and reverse alignment of human self-understanding and care

 

 

Book here

Contact: phenomenologymentalhealth@gmail.com

LLMs and the Patterns of Human Language Use – Christoph Durt

Large Language Models (LLMs) use enormous amounts of data derived from human language use to generate text that is experienced as meaningful by humans. While they replicate stochastic patterns, however, they thereby also prompt patterns of thought and experience. The presentation investigates the relationship between these patterns.

Christoph Durt

Chris Durt is a philosophical researcher and lecturer at the Technical University of Munich. His main research focus is digital technology and the human mind. Rather than seeing digital technology as a mind by itself, he investigates its intricate interrelation with the human mind and other relevant factors such as language and culture. Chris finds phenomenology especially helpful for this investigation, but also builds on insights from Ancient Greek and Early Modern Philosophy, Nietzsche, Wittgenstein, and others. He engages in long-standing interdisciplinary exchanges with psychology, psychiatry, computational linguistics, and AI science. For more information, please see his personal website – www.durt.de

LLMs, Cognitive Biases, and the Path to Cognitive Humility – Marcin Rządeczka & Maciej Wodziński

We are trying to examine the limitations of LLM-based mental health chatbots, highlighting their susceptibility to cognitive biases and the illusion of cognitive humility. We introduce the Simulated Intellectual Humility Scale (SIHS-LLM) to assess epistemic self-awareness in AI and propose strategies for enhancing metacognitive reasoning to improve the epistemic reliability of LLMs.

Marcin Rządeczka

Marcin Rządeczka, Ph.D. is an assistant professor at Maria Curie-Skłodowska University in Lublin, specializes in cognitive science, computational psychiatry, evolutionary psychopathology, and the philosophy of AI for mental health. His research explores cognitive biases, simulated Theory of Mind in AI, and the epistemic challenges of neurodiverse-friendly artificial intelligence. He has contributed to interdisciplinary studies on the role of AI in mental health, and the evolutionary perspective on cognitive biases in autism and schizophrenia spectra. As the head of the Multimodality Research Laboratory (MultiLab), he integrates philosophical, computational, and psychological approaches to understanding human cognition and AI alignment in therapeutic contexts.

Maciej Wodziński

Maciej Wodziński, Ph. D. is a researcher at the Institute of Philosophy, Maria Curie-Skłodowska University in Lublin, Poland. His research focuses on the philosophy of mental health, with a particular interest in epistemic injustice in psychiatric practice and critical autism studies. His interests also extend to the role of AI in philosophy, especially in using AI to analyze first-person experiences of neurodivergent individuals. His work aims to bridge philosophy, mental health, and AI to develop more just and nuanced approaches to neurodiversity.

Quantifying Borderline Experience – Marcin Moskalewicz

Limits of Formalization. Which Aspects of Human Experience Can Enter AI Models? Marianne Broeker

Computational psychiatry is a quickly evolving discipline that aims to understand psychopathology in terms of algorithmic processes. While cognitive phenomena, especially beliefs or ways of “reasoning”, can more easily be formalized, meaning re-described in mathematical terms and then entered computational models, there is speculation as to whether phenomenology might be formalizable too. Here, we explore the possibility of formalizing and modeling a phenomenological account of schizophrenia and other mental illnesses, using concepts from phenomenology, such as of “minimal self” and “intentionality”. We then try to apply the concepts to a computational logic, to test whether an AI can “possess” them. Overall, we are asking via what conditions phenomenology can enter a computational logic.

Marianne Broeker

Marianne D. Broeker is a 3rd year PhD student at the Department of Experimental Psychology at the University of Oxford. Her research looks at changes in conscious in psychosis and takes place at the intersection of clinical psychology and philosophy. However, she is also very interested and in the philosophy of psychiatry and social sciences related to psychiatry, as well as political activism. She has written about and critiqued computational approaches to understanding psychiatric categories and other complex psychological phenomena. Next to her academic work, she works as a existential-analytic psychotherapist in a practice in London.


An gentle introduction to computational (neuro) phenomenology – Maxwell J. D. Ramstead

This presentation gently introduces the field of computational (neuro) phenomenology which is premised on novel advances in computational (generative) modelling. I first present the basic concepts and formal elements of generative modelling. I then examine how one can leverage these advances in the generative modelling of lived experience to further the contemporary project of neurophenomenology.

Maxwell J. D. Ramstead

Maxwell J. D. Ramstead is Chief Science Officer at Noumenal Labs and an Honorary Research Fellow, Queen Square Institute of Neurology, University College London, where he works closely with Karl Friston. Ramstead’s research focuses on on the free-energy principle, Bayesian mechanics, multiscale active inference, and computational phenomenology. Since 2020, Ramstead has moved moved into the field of artificial intelligence, both in academic research and industry.

Psychopathology and AI: How Analytic German Idealism May Bridge the Gap – Prof Peter Schönknecht

Search the VBP Website